As I’ve been working with Magento for a long time I thought it was time to get started with another framework to broaden my horizons, and Symfony seems like a pretty good choice to get in to right now, especially due to platforms and applications like Oro and Sylius using the framework, so I’ve decided to take the plunge and do a bit of work in Symfony. As always with me, the problem with learning a new language or framework is the question of, “what am I going to write?”, fortuanately this time around I’ve got something that I would quite like to write - a personal finance tracking application, basically just something where I can add accounts, import transactions from my bank, create budget forecasts, etc etc. So, with this in mind, I shall create an appropriately named app called cabbage. Why not?

A couple of points:

  • I’m talking about Symfony2
  • I might compare things to Magento a bit, forgive me


I’m following the Symfony book to get me started. The first thing that strikes me is how thoroughly documented Symfony is - this is light years away from when I was learning Magento! I had a brief read of the first couple of chapters - chapter one reinforces the fact that Symfony (and indeed all PHP frameworks) are there for (usually) one purpose; to answer a HTTP request and send a HTTP response. This might be obvious to some people but I think this simplicity of focus is often lost in todays plethora of technologies involved in your average application stack. The second chapter is quite nice as well too actually - it highlights why you would use a framework like Symfony by comparing a typical application implemented in plain ol’ PHP to that same app in Symfony - quite a refreshing reminder of the pain that caused you to shift to MVC a long time ago, a pain which may have now faded in your mind!

Installing Symfony

The book wanted me to use the Symfony Installer, hmm, not the biggest fan of having to use tools like this simply to install a project, what is wrong with git clone or composer? We’ll see in time if this command line tool provides me with any real benefits, right now I’m a bit sceptical of it, anyway, here we go:

curl -LsS -o ~/bin/symfony
chmod +x ~/bin/symfony
symfony new cabbage

Well that worked nicely, and the output tells me I can run a webserver (using PHP 5.5’s built in webserver), so lets try that…

cd cabbage
php app/console server:run

Well that was the easiest project setup I’ve ever done! Whilst it would seem a good idea to get a VM running (because in order to run locally, I’m going to have to install MySQL on my mac) but I plan to use this webserver initially until I’m serious about the project, which is exactly what it is for I suppose, great!

Finally, lets commit the project. I find git invaluable when learning, because I often change a file and forget about it, or perhaps I don’t work on the project for a few days, but git refreshes my memory and gets me right back up to speed. The first thing I would do with Magento is to spend ages figuring out where the hell I put my stock .gitignore, be unable to find it, spend a while looking at ones available online, use them, figure they are no good, whittle them down, and finally end up with something reasonable, but with Symfony, what’s this? It looks like there is already a .gitignore present, awesome! So it really is a case of:

git add -A
git ci -m "Initial commit"

So, now I’m ready to do development - seriously impressed with Symfony so far.

Removing The Demo Bundle

Oh ok, not quite - seems we have a module present called AcmeDemoBundle, and I have a phobia of leaving any demo stuff around - I like to start from a clean slate, so this has to go - if I need to look at code from it, I’ll create a new Symfony project with it in.

By the way, for those that don’t know, a bundle is the name Symfony gives to a self-contained collection of code/config/etc, basically think “module”, or “extension”, well Symfony calls it a bundle. The book says that there is no point having bundles that rely on one another, and that in this case you should use one bundle - this sounds a bit idealist I think, I’m pretty sure that in practice this won’t hold up. It sounds great to have a UserBundle and an AccountsBundle in theory, but in reality I can imagine there will be overlap that is hard to resolve, hopefully I’m wrong. Regardless, apparently I should be using AppBundle only for my cabbage code, I suppose this wouldn’t be true if you were making a framework like Oro, but for me it sounds reasonable, although a far cry from my Magento roots where you would many small modules, each serving a single purpose - I’ll do as told though, and see how it goes.

Anyway, back to removing the demo bundle, looks like Symfony puts all of “my stuff” in to src, and I can see Acme\DemoBundle in there, so I’ll just remove that i suppose…

Ah, no. I refresh the page and am greeted with an error page:

ClassNotFoundException in AppKernel.php line 24: Attempted to load class “AcmeDemoBundle” from namespace “Acme\DemoBundle”. Did you forget a “use” statement for another namespace?

Hm, ok, so it looks like the bundle was registered in app\AppKernel.php, I had to go in and remove line 24 from the file. Lets try again…ah no, another error:

Bundle “AcmeDemoBundle” does not exist or it is not enabled. Maybe you forgot to add it in the registerBundles() method of your AppKernel.php file? in @AcmeDemoBundle/Resources/config/routing.yml (which is being imported from “/Users/mike/Projects/cabbage2/app/config/routing_dev.yml”). Make sure the “AcmeDemoBundle” bundle is correctly registered and loaded in the application kernel class. If the bundle is registered, make sure the bundle path “@AcmeDemoBundle/Resources/config/routing.yml” is not empty.

So, looks like the error is to do with routing_dev.yml, and sure enough, we have lines in the routing file for our bundle:

# AcmeDemoBundle routes (to be removed)
    resource: "@AcmeDemoBundle/Resources/config/routing.yml"

Having removed these, I now get a error saying there is no route, which sounds fine, looks like we’ve removed the bundle. This is the first part of Symfony I do not like though - I think I should be able to delete a directory and the bundle should be gone, why do I have to edit two global files? To me, this seems quite strange, how would I download a bundle and have it automatically activated? In Magento I can disable a module by removing one XML file, which means that conversely, I can download and activate a module without altering any core files, so this concept seems quite alien to me.

Hello, World!

Right, we’re finally ready to get going! As I’ll be making a personal finance tracker I will want to be able to list, add and edit accounts, so I’ll make a controller which will serve a request of /accounts - right now I’ll just make it serve a “Hello, world!” page.

My Magento instincts tell me this is the time to create a module, ready for a controller, however I will follow the book and use the AppBundle for my code. First of all, the book is asking me to declare my routing configuration, though having had a look in app/config/routing.yml it looks like the config for AppBundle is already present:

    resource: "@AppBundle/Controller/"
    type:     annotation

This YAML isn’t the same as the book tells me to make, which is this:

    resource: "@AcmeDemoBundle/Resources/config/routing.yml"
    prefix:   /

I remember from chapters 1 and 2 that the first example instructs Symfony to map controllers and methods to routes via @annotations, whereas the second uses the routing.yml in the bundle to do the mapping. It seems to me that annotations are the cleanest way to do what I want, so I’ll use those, so I don’t need a routing.yml in my bundle, so lets make the controller…

Oh, we already have one! A file exists called src/AppBundle/Controller/DefaultController.php, which has an indexAction(), with annotations that map /app/example to itself, surely enough, visiting that URI results in “Homepage.” being displayed.

So far, so good - I’m not keen on the name of DefaultController though, I’ll rename this file as AccountController.php and change the class name, and change the annotation so this controller serves the route of /accounts, so right now my controller looks like this:

namespace AppBundle\Controller;

use Sensio\Bundle\FrameworkExtraBundle\Configuration\Route;
use Symfony\Bundle\FrameworkBundle\Controller\Controller;

class AccountController extends Controller
     * @Route("/accounts", name="Account List")
    public function indexAction()
        return $this->render('default/index.html.twig');

Testing it results in the same “Homepage.” text being shown, so that worked a treat, so now I’ll change the twig to read “Hello, world!”. I can’t find the twig in the AppBundle, which I thought I would - a project search reveals the file is in app/Resources/views/default/index.html.twig, which has this content:

{% extends 'base.html.twig' %}

{% block body %}
{% endblock %}

So this looks like our candidate for change, and sure enough, changing the text to read “Hello, world!” causes the page to update. It does seem a bit odd to me that this template resides outside of the bundle that it is consumed, and having completed chapter 4 of the Symfony book I know that templates can reside within the bundles themselves, so I’m unsure why this template (which is used only by the AppBundle) does not reside with AppBundle. I might change this convention for the cabbage app.

Wrap Up

We’re done, that seemed far too easy! Only a couple of things struck me as odd, and they were:

  1. It feels odd having to update AppKernel.php and routing.yml to remove a bundle, I’ll just accept this as “The way” for now, perhaps others have come up with solutions for this issue, I’ll find out in time
  2. Having the twig templates for the AppBundle reside in app/Resources feels wrong, I know I could move these templates, but what is the “right” way?

Symfony certainly feels very flexible, and I can foresee that, as someone who likes to do things in the accepted way, I can see this as both an upside and a downside, as it seems things can be acheived in many ways, i.e. config in YAML or PHP, routing via YAML or annotations, templates in bundles or app, etc etc. All in all though, the whole framework feels like a joy to use, which is great.

I think I’ll look at making some edit forms next time, either that or creating some data persistance with MySQL and Doctrine, though as I’m figuring my way around, the path may change!